Research comparison • 18 Nov 2026Index evidence • Not live-verified
Simulation-first • World models • Kit-bashed hardware

Build the nervous system in sim first. The evidence says yes — but not losslessly.

You asked for 100 independent case studies on building a robot's perception, world model, control and planning in simulation before building the body — plus low-cost kit-bashed hardware. This page is that corpus, honestly audited, and put head-to-head against our own work: the browser physics sim, the pyramid stacking runs (master50 → master83), and the plan to kit-bash a cheap physical rig.

Corpus 100 entries Split 50 / 40 / 10 — on-topic / related / kaleidoscope Tags [published] [reported] [estimated] [unknown] Our baseline master83: 6/10 — best real score yet

The honest funnel — read this first

The brief said “100 independent.” The audit says that label is wrong — and that matters for how much weight to give any single claim.

Entries collected
100
Distinct contributions
98
Independent evidence units
73
Research programs
~48

Duplicates collapsed: SO-101 described 3× (R16–R18). Largest clusters tied at 7% each — SO-101 / LeRobot (7 entries) and ETH legged locomotion + Isaac Gym (7 entries). Top 5 clusters = ~30% of the corpus. Full audit in notes/04-audit.md. Two entries (OT17, OT44, FREEDERIA — 85% and 92% claims) are from an unverified outlet and are excluded from strongest findings.

Source note on the count: the audit file’s header first writes “97 distinct contributions,” then Step 1 recounts and restates it as 98 (“only the SO-101 triple collapses, −2”) — the figure report.md also uses. This page follows the revised final count (98); the 73 units and ~48 programs are unchanged in both versions.

Bottom line for our build

Randomization breadth beats simulator fidelity. Every success pairs sim with a transfer mechanism. Pure sim with no randomization fails.

  • DR-trained policies: 87–100% across randomization levels vs 40% nominal-trained (OT15)
  • Sim success is an unreliable predictor of real success (OT16)
  • Browser physics has zero validating primary sources in the corpus
The comparison you asked for

100 studies vs. our research

Our research = the browser-first stack you’ve been building: physics sim as the nervous-system testbed, trajectory / wrench / stability checks for stacking, creep and repair logic, and a low-cost kit-bash path to hardware. Here’s where the published corpus lands on each bet.

Our bet / findingWhat the corpus saysVerdict
Build control & planning in sim before the body existsField default for Dactyl, ANYmal, Dreamer, modern VLAs. Massey digital-twin thesis (n=4, [published]): −1 month / NZD 8,080; −44% cost / NZD 9,380; −20.84% / NZD 42,500; −2 months / NZD 19,280. Virtual commissioning: 14 → 6 days on-site, 47 → 8 change orders, one $180k error caught (OT27, [reported]).Confirmed
World model as the robot’s internal model — predict, then actHa & Schmidhuber V-M-C: CarRacing 906±21, VizDoom 1092±556 trained purely in dream [published] (OT10). DreamerV3: 150+ tasks, one config, first Minecraft diamonds from scratch (OT09). TD-MPC2 scales to 80–100+ tasks decoder-free (OT12). Cosmos Policy: LIBERO 98.5%, real ALOHA 93.6%, best-of-N +12.5 pts [published] (OT13).Confirmed — architecture matters
Browser sim (Three.js / cannon-style) is enough to develop the nervous systemNo retrieved primary source validates browser physics for robot control. Corpus validates MuJoCo / PyBullet / Isaac-class engines. Closest analogues: Webots (open, scriptable) and PyBullet (pip-install, ~30 s) for prototyping, MuJoCo as fidelity step-up. Report §4 & “Could not verify.”Gap — treat as logic testbed
Trajectory check should veto a bad placement — master83: B caught a real 72 mm shove on supporters, build went ahead anyway, J + C fell; C’s repair never firedCorpus agrees checks must gate action: OT30 zero-net-wrench release criterion — 100% basic stacking, only 17% on adjustment cases, 46 trials [published]. OT29 infers placement stability from tactile + F/T contact patch. OT31 uses symbolic thresholds (fn ≥ fmin; slip |v| ≥ vth → re-grasp) with [unknown] measured values. No plug-in threshold exists — you must measure yours.Confirmed — and explains master83
Repair / recovery logic after a disturbance (creep test passed clean on master83; J carried back into slot)Supported in principle: ANYmal fall recovery learned in sim (OT04), ADR widening as policy succeeds (OT03), DayDreamer learning on real robots within hours (OT11). But Dactyl shows cost: median 11.5 real rotations vs 50 in sim [published] — recovery that looks solved in sim overstates real by ~4× on contact-rich tasks.Direction right, discount sim score
Sim score predicts real score — chase the sim numberDirectly refuted. Abekenov SAC push (OT16): sim 79% sparse/dense, 67% with DR; real 80% straight-line / 50% overall for DR policy. Lowest-sim-success policy was the only deployable one. Lateral/diagonal pushes failed — outside training distribution.Refuted
Kit-bash a capable arm for $100–500Proven at component level. SO-101 pair $259 kit / $229.88 parts, 500 g payload (Pro) [published] (R16). Arctos $300–500, 2 kg, 600 mm, ±5 mm repeatability. Moveo $300–500 [reported] (conflicts: ~$600–800 / ~$1k elsewhere). Trade-off is repeatability: Arctos ±5 mm vs OpenManipulator-X <0.2 mm at $1,629.Confirmed — budget motors, not plastic
Printing solves the cost problemNo. Actuators/compute dominate in every build: OpenManipulator-X servos $1,551.95 of $1,629.09 (95%); Poppy 60% actuators; ToddlerBot 90% computer+motors (R37). 3D printing removes the machine shop, not the motor bill.Reframe budget
What this means for master84+: Keep the browser sim for logic, planning, and trajectory vetoes — that’s what it’s good at. Validate dynamics in MuJoCo before trusting a stacking threshold. Widen randomization (mass, friction, offset, lighting) instead of chasing prettier physics. And make the trajectory check a hard gate, not a warning — OT30 and master83 fail the same way when adjustment cases are waved through.
Dimension 1

Sim-to-real transfer: what breaks

Transfer works, never losslessly. The gap is dominated by contact / friction / tendon dynamics, actuator lag & gain, and out-of-distribution poses — not by rendering.

1.5 cm

Tobin 2017 (OT01) — sim-only RGB → real localization [published]. Foundational visual DR result.

11.5 vs 50

Dactyl (OT02) — median consecutive rotations, real vs sim [published]. ~100 years sim in 50 h on 6,144 cores.

60% / 20%

Rubik’s Cube (OT03) — typical / hardest scrambles solved [published] with ADR. ~13,000 years sim claimed [reported].

Locomotion & manipulation anchors

ANYmal speed
1.5 m/s

25% above prior 1.2 m/s record; 23–36% less torque than model-based control [published] (OT04). Fix was learning actuator dynamics from real data.

AME-2 parkour
2 m/s

Zero-shot on ANYmal-D + biped [reported] (OT21). Elevation-map error caps other systems at 0.6 m/s (OT06).

World-action zero-shot
35%

Real Franka average, no real demos (OT14) [published] vs 5% diffusion policy with 10 real demos. Far from deployable — but directionally real.

What fixes it

  • Randomization breadth (ADR / DR) — most replicated technique, Tobin 2017 → Cosmos Policy 2026.
  • Learned actuator models from real data inside the sim (OT04).
  • DR-trained policies hold: 87–100% across DR levels vs 40% nominal (OT15, Sim2Cell / SO-101).
  • What doesn’t fix it: prettier graphics alone. R27: 11.5× lux drop barely moved success (−2.5 pts) because auto-exposure equalized brightness −3%.
Dimension 2

World models: from dream to policy

The lineage is clean: separate V-M-C → unified RSSM → decoder-free latent MPC → video-foundation world-action models.

Measured performance

ModelResult
World Models (OT10) Ha & Schmidhuber 2018CarRacing 906±21 (first solve >900); VizDoom 1092±556 in dream [published]
DreamerV3 (OT09)150+ tasks, one config; Minecraft diamonds from scratch [published]. Independent repro: humanoid 1049.99 vs ~193 random on T4 in ~3–4 h (OT49)
TT-MBRL (OT48)Memory Maze 13×13: 46.2 → 185.0 with test-time adaptation [published]
Cosmos Policy (OT13)LIBERO 98.5%, RoboCasa 67.1%, real ALOHA 93.6% [published]
GR00T 2 (OT41)95% avg over 50 tasks after 5 demos/task [reported] — vendor, not peer-reviewed

3D representations — caution

Gaussian-splat MPC manipulates granular media with zero-shot generalization [reported] (OT34). SPLANNING gives rigorous collision-probability bounds in splats with a real 7-DoF demo [reported] (OT35).

Caveat (R34): Splats are rendering primitives, not collision geometry. Conversion to planner-safe geometry is required — renders don’t certify safe contact. Directly relevant to any splat-based world building.

DayDreamer (OT11): world models learn on real robots within hours [reported] — the clearest evidence imagination cuts real interaction time.

Dimension 3

Kit-bash costs: the motor bill is the bill

Source’s own numbers, with tags. Prices dated Nov 2026 or as stated in source and will move.

BuildCostPayload / note
EEZYbotARM (R39)~$30 [reported]Toy-class, SG90 servos; payload [unknown]
SO-101 pair (R16)$259 kit / $229.88 parts [published]500 g (Pro) [published]; 6 DoF, LeRobot-native; 11,788 datasets on HF (2026-11-01)
Aero Hand Open (R30)$314 [published]7 DoF, 16 joints, 389 g
Arctos 6-axis (R19)$300–500 [published]2 kg, 600 mm reach; ±5 mm repeatability
BCN3D Moveo (R20)$300–500 [reported]0.5 kg, 625 mm, ±0.1 mm — conflicts: ~$600–800 / ~$1k elsewhere
CRAFT hand (R32)~$600 [reported]15 active + 5 passive DoF
XLeRobot bimanual mobile (R24)~$1,200 [published]1.0 kg/arm; vs Mobile ALOHA ~$32k
RUKA hand (R31)<$1,300 [published]6 kg power grasp; 2.74 N pinch, 33 N slip
IRIS cinema arm (R22)<$1,000 [published]1.5 kg, ~1 mm repeatability, 940 mm reach
OpenManipulator-X (R23)$1,629.09 [published]500 g, <0.2 mm; servos = $1,551.95 (95% of cost)
LEAP Hand (R28)$2,000 [published]15 N/finger [reported]; 16 DoF, <4 h assembly
Berkeley Humanoid Lite (R37)$4,312 US / $3,236 China [published]0.8 m, walks
Poppy Humanoid (R37)$8,000–9,000 [published]60% of cost is actuators

Policy scaling on the cheap arm (R25)

On SO-101, ACT from scratch wins at scale: 1/40 @ 12 demos → 37/40 @ 100 demos [published]. π0.5 best when data is scarce (16/40 @ 12). SmolVLA never started in 47% of episodes. 1,340 scored episodes over 17 days, one task/arm/operator — one-task limit noted.

ACT vs Diffusion on SO-101 (R26)

Demonstrated positions: ACT 83.3% vs DP 81.7%. Interpolated positions: ACT 72.5% vs DP 52.5% (−10.8 vs −29.2 pts drop) [published]. ACT generalizes better between demos — relevant if you’re training from few demos.

Dimensions 4 & 5

Platforms & does sim-first actually save time?

Simulation platforms

EngineSpeed / note
MuJoCo10–50× realtime / CPU core; cold start <1 s; best contact solver; only open-source differentiable engine (R05)
PyBullet2–10× realtime; best for quick prototyping / RL flexibility (R12)
Isaac Sim / Gym1–5× (GPU); thousands of envs/GPU; 4,096-env locomotion in <20 min (OT06)
Gazebo0.5–1×; cold start 10–60 s; ROS-native
Genesis (R09)Unified rigid/MPM/SPH/FEM/fluid + generative scenes

Speed figures are rules of thumb [reported] (R05), not benchmark papers. Cost: MuJoCo/Gazebo/PyBullet/Webots/Genesis free (Apache/MIT); Isaac free-ish under NVIDIA EULA, needs NVIDIA GPU; Unity Industry $4,950/seat/yr (K09).

Time & cost saved — strongest evidence

  • RL training: 12–120 h → <20 min for quadruped locomotion [published] (OT06)
  • Virtual commissioning (OT27): ROI 3:1–5:1 [reported]; cycle-time prediction within 3–5%
  • ABB vendor claim: −40% deployment cost, −50% time-to-market [reported] (OT26) — “up to” framing
  • Auto OEM (K07): −10 months, −65% cost [reported] — anonymized vendor case
  • PTC (K06): −26–30% labor/prototype cost [reported]

Counter-evidence stays on the page: OT16 (sim misleads), OT03 (40% failure after ~13,000 years sim), OT14 (35% zero-shot), OT50 (DreamerV3 data-efficiency only weakly confirmed in traffic).

Dimension 6 — closest to our pyramid work

Stacking & placement: methods exist, plug-in numbers don’t

100% / 17%

OT30 — Zero-net-wrench release. Basic stacking vs adjustment cases, 46 trials [published]. ATI Axia80 F/T sensor; gradient descent to zero external torque. Adjustment is where stacking dies — same pattern as master83.

—

OT29 — Contact-patch inference. Stability inferred from tactile + F/T during gentle contact on Bandu pieces [reported]. Quantitative accuracy in paper, not extracted [unknown]. Needs tactile + F/T sensing.

33 N

Nearest grasp anchors. RUKA slip threshold 33 N before fingertip slip [published] (R31) and Tobin 1.5 cm localization (OT01) are the closest quantitative anchors. No published grasp-offset threshold was found.

Implication: For stacking/placement, the literature offers methods (wrench-zeroing, contact-patch estimation) but not numbers to copy. Thresholds must be measured on your own rig — which is exactly what the pyramid runs have been doing.
Kaleidoscope — 10 cross-domain patterns

Why the pattern rhymes outside robotics

Biology: nervous system first is ancestral

Neurons & nerve nets predate brains by hundreds of millions of years; bilaterian ancestor ~700–650 Mya (K01) [published]. Conserved control architecture reused across wildly different bodies for ~600 My (K02, Arendt et al.) — the biological analogue of a portable control stack.

Film: kit-bashing as engineering

ILM industrialized kit-bashing; OED earliest “kitbash” citation 1972 (K03). Scarcity + scrap drove the “used future” — salvaged parts carry functional plausibility (K04). Greeble detail signals function (K05) — a loose parallel to why visual detail/randomization matters in sim-to-real.

Industry: sim-first beyond robots

PTC/Siemens synthesis: prototypes ~−50%, labor/prototype −26–30% [reported] (K06). One OEM: −10 months, −65% cost (K07). UE5 emerging as robotics sim platform for photorealism (K08) — vendor advocacy, no measured transfer numbers [unknown].

Browse the corpus

All 100 entries — grouped

Search or filter. Each entry carries its primary source in the research notes; relevance is direct / adjacent / distant as tagged by the researchers.

Could not verify — open questions (from the report, verbatim scope)
  • Browser-physics (Three.js / cannon.js) fidelity for robot control development — no primary source retrieved.
  • Published numeric thresholds for stacking stability, contact-aware placement, or grasp-offset measurement — methods exist (OT29–OT31), plug-in numbers do not.
  • FREEDERIA figures (OT17: 85%; OT44: 92%) — unverified outlet; excluded from strongest findings.
  • Exact per-task numbers for OT05, OT18, OT20, OT24, OT39, OT42, OT43 — sources retrieved were summaries; figures exist in the papers but were not extracted.
  • All entries are index evidence (search-result text); none was verified live in the research browser. Prices are dated Nov 2026 or as stated and will move.