Math redone from scratch · Prices 11 Nov 2026 · USD, before tax/shipping

50 lb. No legs. Actually cheap.

Legs failed because every joint had to hold up the weight — 8.6 N·m static, 13–17 N·m peak. Wheels put the weight on an axle and a bearing. The motor only has to push it: 1.5–12% of the weight on flat ground. That one change drops the cheapest working carrier from “impossible under $300” to $180.

Cheapest credible carrier that genuinely moves 50 lb
$180 nominal parts

Used hoverboard donor — hacked with free FOC firmware — on a steel-angle / plywood deck with two swivel casters. Phone-controlled.

  • ~1 m/s (walking pace), 45–90 min runtime
  • Flat, hard gravel, short grass only
  • 10° slope in short bursts only
  • Even with a $40 replacement battery + $25 charger: ≈ $245

✓ Under $300 — salvaged / import-direct only

The honest caveat

No credible all-new, US-retail, job-site build — mud, curbs, 20° grass slope, 60 minutes — fits under $300.

  • Cheapest new-parts wheeled: $293 on paper, $320–380 delivered
  • Cheapest tracked (DIY belts): ≈ $414
  • Best-value job-site: wheelchair donor, $219 free / $319 at $100

Shipping is not in any nominal total. It’s the main reason the sub-$300 stacks are fragile. What drives cost isn’t motors — it’s battery + charger ($40–130), drivers + control ($25–65), wheels/tracks ($40–110), and frame/fasteners ($40–70).

Pick a stack — tap for the full parts list

Four complete stacks. No total omits controller, driver, battery, charger, or fasteners. Items marked est. in the lists had no single citable US listing on 11 Nov 2026 — they’re honest estimates, not quotes.

The torque lab — drag it, watch the numbers move

Same formulas as the research, live. This is why wheel size and slope matter more than motor brand — and why a motor whose stall torque equals the number below is still not enough. Work at ≤40–50% of stall.

Drive calculator — 50 lb payload on board

Force to move
—
Torque / drive wheel
—
continuous, at this slope & surface
Stall torque you actually need
—
working at ~45% of stall
Wheel speed needed
—
pick a 60–130 rpm gearmotor
Electrical power
—
Battery for 60 min at this load
—
usable Wh — nominal Li-ion needs ÷0.85, SLA ÷0.50

The formulas

Froll = weight × Crr  ·  Fslope = weight × sin(θ)
Torque/wheel = (Ftotal ÷ drive wheels) × wheel radius
Pmech = Ftotal × speed  ·  Pelec = Pmech ÷ 0.70

Crr used here — conservative values for small, low-pressure pneumatic wheels: hard 0.015, gravel 0.040, grass 0.070, mud 0.120. Bicycle calculators quote 0.002–0.02 for big high-pressure tyres — those do not apply to 6–10-in robot wheels that sink and scrub.

Design rule that falls out

Size for ≈5 N·m per wheel continuous on 8-in wheels (2WD, 10° grass) and ≈8–10 N·m peak (20° grass / mud / starting on a slope). So the target is stall ≥10–13 N·m per wheel for 2WD, or ≥6–7 N·m for 4WD.

That’s exactly what a goBILDA 5203 99.5:1 (stall 13.1 N·m) or a geared MY1016Z (≈15–20 N·m output) provides — and what a Pololu 37D 100:1 (stall 3.3 N·m) does not, even in 4WD on a slope.

Acceleration adds more on top: 0.5 m/s² on an 85-lb vehicle is +19.3 N, about +1 N·m per 2WD 8-in wheel. Starting on a slope is the worst case.

The math, in full

Reference case throughout: 35-lb vehicle + 50-lb payload = 85 lb gross (38.6 kg, 378 N). Four weight cases were carried through the research — light wheeled 75 lb, tracked/heavy 100 lb, wheelchair donor 140 lb.

Surface (85 lb, flat)CrrForce10° slope total20° slope total
Hard concrete0.0151.3 lb / 5.7 N16.0 lb / 71 N30.3 lb / 135 N
Gravel0.0403.4 lb / 15.1 N18.2 lb / 81 N32.5 lb / 144 N
Grass0.0706.0 lb / 26.5 N20.7 lb / 92 N35.0 lb / 156 N
Mud0.12010.2 lb / 45.4 N25.0 lb / 111 N39.3 lb / 175 N

Slope dominates everything. Grade force alone at 10° is 14.8 lb on the 85-lb vehicle; at 20° it’s 29.1 lb — before rolling resistance. A person can push a car on flat ground for the same reason these flat numbers are tiny: rolling force is only 1.5–12% of the weight.

Power at walking pace (1 m/s, 85 lb)

Grass: 27 W mech flat · 92 W mech / 132 W elec at 10° · 156 W / 223 W elec at 20°.
Mud: 45 W flat · 111 W / 159 W elec at 10° · 175 W / 250 W elec at 20°.
Hard: just 6 W flat — but 135 W / 193 W elec at 20°.

Halve at 0.5 m/s, ×1.5 at 1.5 m/s. A 250 W motor per side (500 W total) has ample headroom; 100 W per side is marginal on a 20° grass slope.

Battery for 30 / 60 minutes

Average draw isn’t the slope peak — a job-site duty cycle is mostly flat/grass with slope bursts:

Light flat (25 W avg): 25 Wh usable for 60 min
Mixed grass (60 W avg): 60 Wh usable for 60 min
Rough / slope-heavy (120 W avg): 120 Wh usable for 60 min

Real packs: 2× 12 V 7 Ah SLA ≈ 84 Wh usable (60 min mixed, 30 min rough) · hoverboard 36 V 4.4 Ah ≈ 134 Wh usable · 2× 12 V 20 Ah LiFePO4 = 512 Wh nominal (≈230 Wh usable each).

Why tracks don’t win on torque: use the sprocket pitch radius, not track length. A 3-in sprocket on the 85-lb vehicle needs only 1.76 N·m per track at 10° grass — but add 1.5–2× for skid-steer scrub in a turn plus internal friction, and you budget ≈5–8 N·m per track in practice. Tracks win on ground pressure and obstacle climbing, not torque.

Locomotion, head to head

ModeTerrainTurningVerdict
2WD differential
2 driven + casters
Flat ★★★ · gravel ★★ · grass ★★ · mud ★Zero-radius with castersCheapest credible

Lowest complexity & cost. Curb limit ≈ ½ wheel diameter. Keep weight over the driven axle.

4WD skid-steerFlat ★★★ · gravel ★★★ · grass ★★★ · mud ★★Skid — drags tyres, 1.5–2× current, tears grassCheapest job-site

Torque split 4 ways halves per-wheel need. This is what the wheelchair donor gives you.

TrackedFlat ★★ · gravel ★★★ · grass ★★★ · mud ★★★Skid, worst scrub; throws loose tracksBest terrain, worst price

Climbs ~⅓ track height. No cheap retail kit exists — DIY belts only under $100.

Mecanum / omniSmooth floor only — rollers jam & sink outdoorsStrafing, elegantDisqualified

A smooth-floor drivetrain. Not a job-site answer at any price here.

Hybrid wheel-leg / rocker-bogieAll ★★–★★★GoodOut of scope

Linkages + extra actuators. Nowhere near cheapest.

Motors — what actually has the torque

Trap to avoid: sellers quote motor-shaft torque before the gearbox. Cross-check any geared-motor claim with T = 9550 × P(kW) ÷ rpm. A 250 W motor at 120 rpm is 19.9 N·m ideal, ≈15 N·m at 75% efficiency — no matter what the listing headline says.

MotorTorque / speedPrice (11 Nov 2026)Verdict
Hoverboard hub, 6.5-in, 36 V, 250–350 W ea.10–15 N·m peak at 15 A · 5–10 N·m continuous · wheel is the motor~$10 used / $15 eBay / $35 new ea.Best torque per $ Needs FOC driver (hacked stock board). Solid 6.5-in tyre is the rough-ground limit.
MY1016Z geared, 24 V 250 W, 120 rpm≈15–20 N·m rated output (calc.) · ~13 A rated$38 ea. import-direct · $86–119 US retailBest new buy 2 needed. The $293 Stack B total lives or dies on the $38 import price.
goBILDA 5203 Yellow Jacket 99.5:1, 12 VStall 13.1 N·m · 60 rpm · 9.2 A stall · encoder incl.$54.99 ea.Honest spec 60 rpm = 0.64 m/s on 8-in wheels — slow. 71.2:1 (84 rpm, 9.2 N·m stall) is the faster pick, same price.
Wheelchair motor + gearbox (salvaged)250–320 W class, transaxle gearingIn donor · $367–1,186 new — never buy newDonor only Comes with wheels + controller in Stack D.
MY1016 high-speed (no gear), 24 V 250 W0.86 N·m · 2,750 rpm$34.99 / $20.99 directNeeds ~25:1 reduction The external reduction costs more than the saving vs the Z version.
Pololu 37D 100:1 / 131:1, 12 VStall 3.3 / 4.4 N·m$60.95 / $38.95Too weak, too dear 4× in 4WD = 17.6 N·m stall total vs ~16 N·m needed at 20° grass — before any margin.
Power Wheels RS550 + plastic gearbox≈5–8 N·m/wheel peak (inferred from 130-lb vehicle rating)$0 salvaged · $3–15 replacementDonor only Plastic gears strip under shock load on rough ground.
E-bike geared hub, 36 V 250 W kit35–43 N·m max~$100–220+ kitWrong form factor Huge torque, but bicycle-size wheel, fork mount, kit price.
Cordless drill / wiper motor (salvage)Drill: 20–40 N·m at chuck in low gear · Wiper: 6.2–15 N·m stall, 30–60 rpm$0–20 junkyardFun, not repeatable Custom mounts, no encoder, intermittent duty (wiper).

Reduction options: built-in planetary ($0 extra, 85–95%/stage) always wins. #25 chain ≈$10–15/side at 95–98%. Timing belt similar, quieter, slips under overload. Worm gear is 50–70% efficient — it holds on a slope for free but roughly doubles battery need; avoid for drive. Sources: Lunyee MY1016Z · goBILDA 5203 · FFBeast hoverboard data · Pololu 37D specs

Donor bases — buy the drivetrain used

Hoverboard — cheapest complete donor

$49 eBay (Jetson, used, no charger, as-is) · $50 Facebook · $80 with charger. Includes 2 hub motors + tyres, 36 V battery, FOC-hackable mainboard.

Trap: dead/weak battery is the rule, not the exception ($40–150 to replace). Board variant matters for the hack — check the Gen2.x wiki before buying. No suspension, no cargo bed.

Power wheelchair — cheapest capable donor ★

Free listings exist (Invacare Pronto M51, no batteries; Permobil, needs battery — Missouri AT, Nov 2026) · $100–500 private · $950–3,500 dealer used. Includes motors, 12–14-in wheels, frame, joystick + controller.

Trap: batteries almost always dead — $200–400/pair as wheelchair SLA, avoided in Stack D with generic LiFePO4. Chair weighs 60–100 lb. Test the joystick before paying.

Power Wheels — cheapest chassis, weakest drive

$20 as-is (“did not charge”) · $75 with new battery · $85–100 working. Includes chassis, 2 motors + gearboxes, 4 wheels.

Traps: plastic gears, dead 12 V SLA ($20–40), hard plastic wheels with poor grass traction, toy steering (remove it, go differential). 50 lb + vehicle on grass is near its design limit.

Also checked and mostly rejected: old mower (wheels + steel deck only — petrol transaxle isn’t reusable), wagon/dolly (you’re buying a trailer, not a drivetrain), dead e-bike/scooter (good for the motor alone; battery usually dead, hub needs a fork). Donor sources: eBay hoverboard listing · MO AT swap listings · used wheelchair guide

Power & control — the lines everyone forgets

Batteries & chargers

2× 12 V 7 Ah SLA (24 V): $38.99/pair · 168 Wh nominal, ~84 usable · ~10 lb
12 V 20 Ah LiFePO4: $52.99 ea. · 256 Wh, ~230 usable · 5.4 lb ea.
Hoverboard 36 V 4.4 Ah: $0 if donor pack is healthy · $40–150 replacement
Chargers: LiFePO4 14.6 V 5 A $13.99 / 10 A $19.99–24.99 · 24 V SLA ≈$20 est.

Never charge Li-ion/LiFePO4 with an SLA charger. Never charge a used hoverboard pack unattended — check for swelling first. LiPo is not recommended here: puncture + job site + fire risk. Drill packs work if you already own the platform (~90–100 Wh each).

Drivers, controller, remote, following

BTS7960 / IBT-2: $6.99 ea. (one per motor) — the default. 43 A peak marketing, ~20 A continuous with airflow.
ESP32 DevKit: $9 — Wi-Fi + Bluetooth, phone joystick is $0 extra.
FlySky FS-i6 + receiver: $49.99–52.92 — add if you want a real RC link that works with gloves.
Hoverboard stock board: $0 in the donor, free FOC firmware, needs a ~$10 ST-Link to flash.

Person-following: don’t budget autonomy into the $300 build. Ultrasonic/ToF follow ($10–30) fails in sunlight and follows any obstacle. The credible outdoor method is UWB — 2× DWM1001 at $22–28 ea. (~$50 total) — added later.

Chassis, wheels, cargo — keep the load path metal

Frame

SteelWorks 1½-in × 36-in steel angle, $13.99 at Menards ($12.45 after 11% rebate — store credit, not instant). Two pieces make the perimeter; bolt it, no welder needed. Plywood deck ½-in 4×8 is $30.90 — a carrier needs ~¼ sheet ($15 allocated).

Plywood is fine as a deck on a metal frame. It is not the load path for axles or motor mounts.

Wheels

Harbor Freight 10-in pneumatic, $9.99 ea., 300-lb working load, knobby tread — the default wheel. 8-in pneumatic swivel caster $16.99 ea., 280-lb rated.

Load is 21–35 lb per wheel on 4 wheels. Don’t use printed drive wheels (hub torque shears them) or hard toy wheels on grass.

Cargo & printed parts

Tote / mixing tub / milk crate bolted to the deck: ~$12 est. Keep the 50 lb low and centred over the driven axle — a high, rear-biased load unloads the drive wheels and kills slope traction.

Printed parts carry no load here. Resin is brittle; FDM creeps and delaminates. Prints are fine for covers, sensor mounts, chain guards, battery boxes, track guides — never motor mounts, axles, or bed supports.

Retail reality check

What finished machines cost

goBILDA Bravo tracked kit — $1,049.99: the only retail kit found with an explicit 50-lb rating (2 mph, battery + charger + RC included). DIY tracks at $414 are 2.5× cheaper because you are the factory.
SuperDroid IG52-DB4 4WD — $1,674+: 50–75-lb payload, 70-lb vehicle. HD2 tracked: $5,692, 100-lb payload.

No sub-$300 retail kit with a verified 50-lb payload on rough ground was found.

⛔ Do not buy for this job

• Pololu 37D motors — too weak, too expensive
• Mecanum wheels — smooth floor only
• New wheelchair motors — $367–$1,186 each
• A retail tracked kit — $1,050+ on this budget
• Mini toy track kits — rated 1.5–2 kg, not 50 lb
• Printed load-path parts — metal or nothing

So — what to build, in order

1 · Budget hard-capped, ground mostly flat → Stack A

Hoverboard donor at $180, phone-controlled. Carries 50 lb at walking pace on flat, gravel, short grass. Won’t do mud, curbs, or a 20° grass slope — and doesn’t pretend to.

2 · No hoverboard available → Stack B

MY1016Z import-direct at $293 nominal ($320–380 delivered). Same job, but 10-in pneumatic wheels make it genuinely better on grass and gravel.

3 · Real job-site terrain → Stack D, not tracks

The wheelchair donor ($219 free / $319 at $100) is the step that buys curbs, mud, slopes, and 2-hour runtime. Only attempt DIY tracks ($414) if no chair can be found — and only if you’re comfortable with belt tensioning and alignment.

4 · Following comes last

Drive it with the phone or a FlySky ($0–50) first. Add UWB follow later for ~$50. Autonomy is a bolt-on, not a foundation.

Open questions & unverified prices — read before ordering

• MY1016Z US-retail price: only direct/Alibaba prices ($38–49) and EU/CA retail (€86 / $119 CAD) were found; no citable Amazon.com USD price on 11 Nov 2026. Stack B’s sub-$300 claim depends on the import price.
• Estimated items (24 V chargers, ST-Link, chain/sprockets, tote, buck/wiring) total $50–90 per stack — plausible ranges, not quotes.
• Power Wheels / drill / wiper torque and mower/wagon donor prices: no citable US listings found; those rows are reasoned from vehicle/tool ratings and labelled as such.
• Shipping & tax excluded throughout. US shipping on motors + battery is typically $15–40 — the gap between Stack B’s $293 nominal and $320–380 realistic.
• No live checkout was performed; prices are from the search index and pages opened 11 Nov 2026. Re-check the MY1016Z, BTS7960, and battery listings before buying.
• Printed-part strength is engineering judgement (layer adhesion / creep), not a tested datasheet for your specific resin/FDM materials.